Bridging Australia and the Arab World

Friday, 20 November 2026

Magistrate Critiques Police for Handling of Family Violence Case

Spread the love

Arabic version: قاضي ينتقد الشرطة بسبب تعاملها مع قضية العنف الأسري

A magistrate has criticized the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) police and prosecutors for their handling of a family violence case, labeling their conduct as “egregious”. This follows the abandonment of charges against a Canberra man who faced 14 counts of family violence, including allegations of sending threatening text messages to a former partner. The case took a dramatic turn when police admitted they could not substantiate the claims against the man, leading to calls for an apology and compensation from his lawyers.

According to ABC News, Magistrate Jane Campbell expressed her astonishment at the two-month delay in addressing evidence that suggested the complainant had fabricated some claims. During a court hearing, the man’s lawyer, Peter Woodhouse, presented evidence indicating that the complainant may have sent threatening messages to herself. This revelation prompted the police officer involved to acknowledge that it appeared the complainant had lied.

The case began dramatically last year, after the ACT’s tactical response team descended on the home the man shares with his mother. His lawyers said the man’s front door was blown up and he was dragged into the street in his underpants, with police pointing automatic weapons at him. Campbell noted that the delay in addressing the fabricated evidence had significantly prejudiced the defendant, who had maintained his innocence.

While the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) defended its actions, stating that the complexity of the case required careful consideration, it faced criticism for not acting sooner. The DPP claimed that it only received a complete report regarding the complainant’s credibility on March 18 and responded within a week.

In light of the situation, ACT Policing announced that a review is underway to assess the events surrounding the prosecution. However, Woodhouse emphasized the profound impact this ordeal has had on his client, asserting that no innocent person should endure such a miscarriage of justice.

About the Author​

More
articles