Arabic version: المحللون يشككون في مزاعم الخلاف بين الولايات المتحدة وإسرائيل بسبب تصرفات نتنياهو

Reports of a heated exchange between US President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu have sparked skepticism among analysts regarding the nature of US-Israel relations. According to Al Jazeera, an anonymous report suggested that Trump berated Netanyahu during a call, labeling him “f***ing crazy” in response to Israel’s escalation in Lebanon.

Despite these claims, experts argue that US support for Israel remains steadfast, regardless of reported tensions. Ryan Costello, policy director at the National Iranian American Council Action, noted that media narratives around US presidential anger towards Netanyahu often lack tangible policy changes. He emphasized that what matters most are the actual outcomes of US-Israel relations.

Isabelle Hayslip from the rights group DAWN echoed this sentiment, stating that the reports of Trump’s frustrations do not align with the reality of US policy, which continues to favor Israeli interests. Hayslip remarked that Netanyahu often receives what he wants from the US, despite any purported disagreements.

The backdrop of these discussions is the ongoing conflict involving Iran, which has seen rising tensions and criticism directed at Trump for his handling of the situation. As negotiations stall, the Israeli military’s actions in Lebanon have raised concerns about escalating violence, further complicating the US’s role in the conflict.

While the Axios report has drawn attention, critics argue that the narrative serves to project a tough stance from the US towards Israel, potentially to mitigate backlash over the ongoing war. However, experts caution that such rhetoric does not translate into changes on the ground, highlighting the complexity of the geopolitical landscape.