Bridging Australia and the Arab World

Tuesday, 17 November 2026

Stephen Noga’s Appeal Over Abuse Ruling Dismissed

Stephen Noga’s Appeal Over Abuse Ruling Dismissed
Spread the love

Arabic version: رفض استئناف ستيفن نوغا بشأن حكم الإساءة

According to ABC News, former Hobart teacher Stephen Fane Noga has lost an appeal against a civil decision that found in favour of a former student who sued over allegations of repeated sexual abuse in the 1980s.

Noga, 76, was sued earlier this year by the former Hobart Matriculation College student, now in her 60s. The woman also brought a case against the State of Tasmania, alleging it failed in its duty of care. Justice Stephen Estcourt found for the terminally ill woman and awarded cumulative damages of $1.6 million.

Noga’s legal team appealed in May on four grounds. It argued that social media posts, reposts and comments by Justice Estcourt, described as generally supportive of victims of sexual abuse, created a perception he would be more likely to rule for the woman. The appeal also alleged legal errors, including in the judge’s assessment of the parties’ evidence.

The Full Court, comprising Justice Robert Pearce, Justice Tamara Jago and Acting Justice Paul Slattery, found Justice Estcourt had not made the factual errors alleged by Noga. It said Noga had correctly identified circumstances giving rise to an apprehension of bias, citing the nature, number and timing of 13 reposts made between February 1 and March 21.

However, the court held that Noga waived his right to object because neither he nor his legal team raised the issue during the trial, despite being sufficiently aware of the circumstances. The case will return to the Court of Appeal on Thursday for a hearing on costs, after the woman’s barrister sought orders for Noga and the state to pay her appeal costs.

About the Author​

More
articles