Arabic version: تاسمانيا تطلب تفسيراً من مجلس الإفراج المشروط بشأن قانون قضائي مولّد بالذكاء الاصطناعي
According to ABC News, Tasmania’s attorney-general has sought an explanation from the Parole Board of Tasmania after AI-generated case law was used in material supporting a condition imposed on convicted murderer Susan Neill-Fraser.
Neill-Fraser served 13 years in prison for murdering her partner, Bob Chappell, aboard their yacht in 2009. She was released on parole in 2022. The board later imposed a condition preventing her from speaking to the media about her claimed innocence or alleged wrongful conviction.
On Tuesday, Justice Stephen Escourt ruled in the Supreme Court in Hobart that the condition was invalid. He found it denied Neill-Fraser procedural fairness, was legally unreasonable and created uncertainty. The court also found the board had relied on a document containing case law that was “fictitious” and likely “AI hallucinations”.
Attorney-General Guy Barnett said the board was independent and the government had no role in its decisions, but said he would write to its chair seeking an explanation of its professional standards. He said inaccurate information produced in the case was “not acceptable” and that he would seek assurances it would not happen again. Mr Barnett also asked the justice department’s head to remind staff to comply with the AI use policy.
Greg Barns SC, chair of Prisoners Legal Service, called for an audit and questioned how broadly the board may have used AI. Human Rights Law Centre legal director Sarah Schwartz said the case exposed “serious deficiencies” in the parole system. Acting Law Society president Luke Taylor said AI use did not remove the responsibility of human decision-makers and warned of risks where safeguards were absent or not followed. The parole board was contacted for comment.
