Arabic version: اقتصاديون يتجادلون: هل الاقتصاد الأميركي على شكل K أم C أم E؟
According to Cnbc, economists, corporate leaders and politicians are debating whether the U.S. economy remains K-shaped or is better described by a C or E. The K-shaped recovery has long referred to unequal expansion, with different groups moving in opposite directions. Joel Mokyr, a Nobel Prize-winning economic historian at Northwestern University, called the competing descriptions “alphabet soup.”
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said earlier this month that the K-shaped economy was over and that a C-shaped economy was forming, with lower-income consumers gaining ground. He cited wage gains among lower earners and larger tax cuts, including President Donald Trump’s “no tax on tips” and “no tax on overtime” policies. Hilton Worldwide CEO Christopher Nassetta also said the company was seeing a C-shaped economy, with middle- and upper-middle segments shifting from negative results to growth of as much as 6%.
Others say the K remains relevant. Anthony Chan, JPMorgan’s former chief economist, said the U.S. war with Iran and potentially higher gas prices could weigh more heavily on lower-income consumers, who spend a greater share of income on energy. University of Michigan consumer sentiment was down 11% in August from a year earlier, with low- and middle-income respondents taking an outsized hit. Executives at Colgate-Palmolive, Lowe’s and Constellation Brands also said they continued to see K-shaped consumer patterns.
Some research points to convergence. A Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond report found consumption showed a clear divide across income groups between 2021 and 2023, even though income growth did not appear to show the same divergence. The Bank of America Institute said the gap in credit-card spending across income classes began narrowing in May. But New York Fed researchers cited combined credit-card balances of nearly $1.26 trillion in the second quarter as evidence that many households live paycheck to paycheck.
The E-shaped view describes three income groups on parallel but unequal tracks. Don Rissmiller of Baird Strategas said each group has found a way to live, in an outcome that looks more stable than not. Heather Long of Navy Federal Credit Union said an E may better capture a middle class that is just hanging on, while Wyndham Hotels & Resorts CEO Geoff Ballotti said conditions could reflect either a C- or E-shaped economy.
